Magic Eden vs Monster

Feature	Magic Eden Pokemon packs on Magic Eden powered by Collector Crypt Crypto checked 2026-10-04 Visit site	Monster Graded Pokemon and One Piece packs, odds printed on every pack page Not stated checked 2026-10-04 Visit site
Measured value
Gross return (measured)? Card value out per dollar in, before cash-out	111.9%best	104.2%
Typical rip (median)?	83.7%best	79.8%
Net take-home on its best pack? Typical rip of the best pack, after the site's own buyback rate	–N/A?	–N/A?
Pulls sampled?	616	28,580best
Packs tracked	4	6best
Getting paid
Withdraw	–N/A?	Yes
Paid out as?	crypto	–N/A?
Payout speed	–N/A?	–N/A?
Buyback rate?	–N/A?	–N/A?
Withdrawal fee	–N/A?	–N/A?
Getting started
Payment methods	–N/A?	–N/A?
Crypto wallet needed	Yes	–N/A?
Minimum buy-in	25	–N/A?
ID check	–N/A?	–N/A?
Where you can buy	–N/A?	–N/A?
Getting your card
Ships the card	Yes	Yes
Ships to	–N/A?	–N/A?
Shipping cost	–N/A?	–N/A?
Vault cost	–N/A?	–N/A?

"Best" marks the highest value in that row only, and only where the row is numerically comparable. It is not an overall verdict: a site can lead on return and trail on payout terms. Returns are gross unless the row says otherwise.

Which of these is right for you

Other comparisons